Leonardo da Vinci's inventions are transfigured into a myth today. In the popular literature then, Leonardo's ideas and ingenuity are often emphasized, but at the same time it is claimed that his apparatuses could never have worked as they did. Still others say that many of the inventions for which Leonardo is praised today were actually inventions of others and that he only copied them. And both are true.
Could Leonardo's inventions work?
Leonardo always carried a sketchpad with him, because ideas often came to him in everyday life, which he wrote down and drew without further explanation. These could also be cursorily sketched models of apparatuses, but not with the claim to be rebuildable. He made these notes only for himself, because while sketching the ideas he thought about their feasibility. If he was then back in his workshop, he put these notes aside and it could happen that he never looked at them again, because he had no more time for them due to other tasks and thoughts or because no practical application purpose resulted from them. This explains why many of his sketches were never put into practice. Conversely, however, it could also become, for example, a large building project, an automaton for a princely feast, or even a painting.
Leonardo's notebooks, called codices, have been partially preserved. Today, the approximately 6,000 pages are distributed among museums in Spain, England, France and Italy. Most of the codices have been digitized and can be viewed online. In 1994 Bill Gates acquired Leonardo's only privately owned manuscript, the Codex Leicester.
Did Leonardo copy the ideas of others?
Leonardo, as a Renaissance scholar, owned an extensive library. In it were various contemporary books, but also works of ancient scholars and engineers such as Plato, Euclid or Archimedes. Leonardo da Vinci, a Renaissance scholar, tried to capture the knowledge of the world known at that time. The contemporary as well as the lost and at that time disparagingly regarded knowledge of the Greek-Roman antiquity. So Leonardo knew many inventions of his and earlier times, dealt with them mentally and tried to improve them where it was possible for him. He had the ambition to collect all known knowledge of his time, to reduce this knowledge to the principles and to develop them further based on this.
Leonardo was also very well connected in the scientific world of Europe, which led to a constant exchange of ideas. From today's perspective, this can give the impression of plagiarism. But from the point of view of the Renaissance scholars, it was precisely a matter of taking up excellent ideas of others, spreading them for the purpose of a common progress of mankind and, in the best case, even improving these ideas. A climate of interdisciplinary scientific exchange developed. In this respect, Leonardo da Vinci copied ancient as well as contemporary ideas, but often also developed them further.